Issue 31
Vanishing Points

On the Trail of Billy Budd: An Analysis of <i>Beau travail</i>

Miguel Olea Romacho
Universidad de Granada
Bio

Published 2021-01-31

Keywords

  • Adaptation,
  • Claire Denis,
  • Melville,
  • Rewriting,
  • Performativity,
  • Queer,
  • Cinema of the Body.
  • ...More
    Less

Abstract

This article offers an analysis of Claire Denis’s film Beau travail (1999) as a free adaptation of Herman Melville’s classic Billy Budd. A comparative perspective is adopted to identify the specific transformations in the rewriting process, with attention to changes in focalisation and plot, as well as the film’s potential as a queer adaptation of Melville’s novella. Central to these relationships is the use of bodies, which creates a narrative that challenges both our expectations of a literary adaptation and the gender conventions of the film medium. In this way, the study finds that Beau travail is a benchmark case for defining transformative potential of adaptations.

References

<p>Alsop, E. (2014). The Mercurial Quality of Being: Sudden Moves in <em>Beau Travail </em>and <em>Billy Budd</em>. <em>Adaptation, 7</em>(1), 14-24.<br>
Del Río, E. (2008). <em>Deleuze and the Cinemas of Performance</em>. Edimburgo: Edinburgh University Press, 2012.<br>
Deleuze, G. (1987). <em>La imagen-tiempo. Estudios sobre cine 2</em>. Barcelona: Paidós.<br>
Fassbinder, R. W. (1992). Preliminary Remarks on <em>Querelle</em>. En M. Töteberg y L. A. Lensing (eds.), <em>The Anarchy of the Imagination: Interviews, Essays, Notes by Rainer Werner Fassbinder </em>(pp. 168-170). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.<br>
Fischer-Lichte, E. (2017). <em>Estética de lo performativo</em>. Madrid: Abada.<br>
Grant, C. (2002). Recognizing <em>Billy Budd</em> in <em>Beau Travail</em>: epistemology and hermeneutics of an auterist &ldquo;free&rdquo; adaptation. <em>Screen, 43</em>(1), 57-73.<br>
Hutcheon, L. (2006). <em>A Theory of Adaptation</em>. Nueva York: Routledge.<br>
Jones, K. (2000). The Dance of the Unknown Soldier. <em>Film Comment, 36</em>(3), 26-27.<br>
Kassabian, A. (2001). <em>Hearing Film: Tracking Identifications in Contemporary Hollywood Film Music</em>. Nueva York y Londres: Routledge.<br>
Kosofsky Sedgwick, E. (1990). <em>Epistemology of the Closet</em>. Londres: Penguin.<br>
Lalanne, J.-M., Larcher, J. (2000). &ldquo;Je me reconnais dans un cinéma qui fait confiance à la narration plastique&rdquo;: Entretien avec Claire Denis. <em>Cahiers du Cinéma, 545</em>, 50-53.<br>
Leroy, A., Ganzo, F. (2020). Entrevista a Laura Mulvey: &ldquo;La mirada femenina exige un espectador activo&rdquo;. <em>Sofilm, 68</em>, 82-85.<br>
Mayne, J. (2005). <em>Claire Denis</em>. Champaign: University of Illinois Press.<br>
Melville, H. (2012). <em>Billy Budd, marinero</em>. En J. Lavid (ed.), <em>Bartleby, el escribiente</em>, <em>Benito Cereno</em>, <em>Billy Budd </em>(pp. 209-303). Madrid: Cátedra.<br>
Pérez Bowie, J. A. (2010). <em>Reescrituras fílmicas: nuevos territorios de la adaptación</em>. Salamanca: Ediciones Universidad de Salamanca.<br>
Renouard, J.-P., Wajeman, L. (2001). Ce poids d&rsquo;ici-bas: Entretien avec Claire Denis. <em>Vacarme, 14</em>, 62-68. <br>
Ropars, M.-C. (1998). L&rsquo;oeuvre au double: Sur les paradoxes de l&rsquo;adaptation. En A. Gaudreault y T. Groensteen (eds.), <em>La transécriture. Colloque de Cerisy</em>. Quebec y Angulema: Nota Bene y Centre national de la bande desinée et de l&rsquo;image.<br>
Rosenbaum, J. (2000, 26 de mayo). Unsatisfied Men. <em>jonathanrosenbaum.net</em>. Recuperado de https://www.jonathanrosenbaum.net/2018/04/unsatisfied-men/<br>
Sánchez Noriega, J. L. (2000). <em>De la literatura al cine: teoría y análisis de la adaptación</em>. Barcelona: Paidós.<br>
Sánchez-Mesa, D. (2009). Entre palabras e imágenes. Un modelo de estudio para las adaptaciones de Don Quijote de la Mancha. En C. Heredero (ed.), <em>El cine y el Quijote </em>(pp. 133-148). Madrid: Sociedad Estatal de Conmemoraciones Culturales.<br>
Stam, R. (2000). Beyond Fidelity: the Dialogics of Adaptation. En J. Naremore (ed.), <em>Film Adaptation </em>(pp. 54-78). Londres: The Athlone Press.<br>
Stam, R. (2005). Introduction: The Theory and Practice of Adaptation. En R. Stam y A. Raengo (eds.), <em>Literature and Film. A Guide to Theory and Practice of Film Adaptation </em>(pp. 1-52). Londres: Blackwell.</p>