Issue 25
Notebook

From the Shot/Reverse Shot to the “Face to Face”. The Figuration of the Gesture in Carol

Arnau Vilaró i Moncasí
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
Bio
Issue 25

Published 2018-01-31

Keywords

  • Carol,
  • Todd Haynes,
  • Subjectivity,
  • Shot/reverse shot,
  • Desire,
  • Gaze,
  • Face to face,
  • Face,
  • Caress,
  • Other,
  • Emmanuel Levinas
  • ...More
    Less

Abstract

In Carol Todd Haynes, 2015), the desire that Therese and Carol feel for each other arouses in the events of separation, whenever there is a (physical) distance between them. The following paper addresses the figuration of the gesture that is built between the gaze of both heroines in the shot/reverse shot, which Haynes draws upon at the beginning and at the end of the film. Borrowing the possibilities of classic melodrama for this purpose, Haynes confronts the viewer with a renewed idea of the shot/reverse-shot in which there is no look that submits to the other, but each one possesses its own subjectivity. The act of looking becomes in Caro a “face to face”, in terms of Emmanuel Levinas, where the Other takes the significance and infinity of the discourse of the self. Gaze, desire, face to face, face, caress. The concepts with which Levinas defines the phenomenology of Eros emerge in Carol as the figures that allow a rereading of Hollywood system concerning desire and the invention of an erotic gesture wrought in the time of the visibility of the other.

References

<p>Agamben, G. (1991). Notes sur le geste. <em>Trafic</em>, 1, p. 31-36.<br>
Barthes, R. (2011). <em>El discurso amoroso. </em>Barcelona: Paidós.<br>
Benjamin, W. (1973). <em>La obra de arte en la época de su reproductibilidad técnica. </em>Madrid: Taurus.<br>
Bou, N. (1996). <em>La mirada en el temps. Mite i passió en el cinema de Hollywood. </em>Barcelona: Edicions 62.<br>
— (2002). <em>Plano/contraplano. De la mirada clásica al universo de Michelangelo Antonioni</em>. Madrid: Biblioteca Nueva.<br>
Bourget, J-L. (1985). <em>Le mélodrame hollywoodien</em>. París: Stock.<br>
Bresson, R. (1975). <em>Notes sur le cinématographe</em>. París: Gallimard.<br>
Ciment, M., Tobin, Y. (2016). «Je voulais exprimer le désir et les obstacles qu&rsquo;il rencontré». Entretien avec Todd Haynes. <em>Positif</em>, 659, 17-21.<br>
Deleuze, G. (2003). <em>La imagen-movimiento. Estudios sobre cine 1. </em>Barcelona: Paidós.<br>
Didi-Huberman, G. (2010). <em>Lo que vemos, lo que nos mira</em>. Buenos Aires: Manantial.<br>
Elliot, N. (2015). Le monde des femmes. Entretien avec Todd Haynes. <em>Cahiers du cinéma</em>, 718, 16-20.<br>
Lechón, M. (coord.) (2000). <em>Todd Haynes: el creador seminal</em>. Festival de Cine de Gijón: CGAI, Institut Valencià de Cinematografia.<br>
Levinas, E. (2012). <em>Totalidad e infinito. Ensayo sobre la exterioridad</em>. Salamanca: Sígueme.<br>
Merleau-Ponty, M. (1966). <em>Lo visible y lo invisible. </em>Barcelona: Seix Barral.<br>
Metz, W. C. (2016). Far From Toy Trains. <em>Film Criticism</em>, 40 (3), n.p. Disponible en: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/f/fc/13761232.0040.303/--far-from-toy-trains?rgn=main;view=fulltext&nbsp;<br>
Morán, A. (2016). Tras el cristal. <em>Caimán Cuadernos de Cine</em>, 46 (97), p. 14.<br>
Oudart, J-P. (2005). La sutura. En Baecque, A. (comp.). <em>Teoría y crítica del cine. Avatares de una cinefilia.</em> Barcelona: Paidós, p. 52-68.<br>
Samocki, J-M. (2016). Vers la réconciliation. Ou comment Todd Haynes termine ses films. <em>Trafic</em>, 98, 28-34.<br>
Stasukevich, I. (2016). Ed Lachman. El lenguaje emocional de la luz. <em>Caimán Cuadernos de Cine</em>, 46 (97), p. 16-22.<br>
Vilaró, A. (2017). <em>La caricia del cine. La invención figurativa de la Nouvelle Vague. </em>Santander: Shangrila.<br>
Viviani, C. (2016). Harmonie des contraires. <em>Carol</em>, Todd Haynes. <em>Positif</em>, 659, p. 14-16.</p>