Issue 23
Vanishing Points

Memory and Mass Graves: Political Strategies of Independent Documentaries.

Josetxo Cerdán
Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
Bio
Miguel Fernandez Labayen
Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
Bio

Published 2017-01-01

Keywords

  • Historical Memory,
  • Mass Grave,
  • Independent Documentary,
  • Spanish Civil War,
  • Pere Vilà,
  • Isaki Lacuesta,
  • Los Hijos Film Collective,
  • Jorge Tur.
  • ...More
    Less

Abstract

This article examines the political strategies of independent Spanish documentaries of the 2000s and 2010s in the context of debates about historical memory. The hypothesis of this research is that independent documentaries can operate as vehicles for practices and discourses that are free from the institutional domestication normally affecting film and television productions dealing with memory. It is thus argued that documentary film practices distanced from official political interests can challenge some of the common assumptions in discussions of historical memory and offer a bottom-up perspective, in parallel with a process that brings a grassroots element into public discussions of memory. First of all, the article examines some of the most prominent theoretical positions on memory. We then analyse the films Soldados Anónimos/Soldats Anònims (Pere Vilà and Isaki Lacuesta, 2009), Los materiales (Los Hijos, 2010) and Dime quién era Sanchicorrota (Jorge Tur, 2013) as examples that illustrate these ideas. Based on a study of these films, we question the use of testimony and the indexical value of the document as the foundations of the discourse of the film documentary, and propose a distancing from these practices as a way of avoiding the sentimental use of memory evident in official political positons on the Spanish Civil War.

References

<p>Aguilar, Paloma (2008). <em>Políticas de la memoria y memorias de la política</em>. Madrid: Alianza Editorial.</p><p>
Arigita, Nieves (2013). Los restos de cinco cadáveres hallados en Bardenas no son de fusilados en el 36. <em>Diario de Noticias</em>, 4 May, p. 33.</p><p>
Ferrándiz, Francisco (2008). Cries and Whispers: Exhuming and Narrating Defeat in Spain Today. <em>Journal of Spanish Cultural Studies</em>, 9:2, pp. 177-192.</p><p>
Hristova, Marije; Douglas, Lee; Kerangat, Zoé de and Ferrándiz, Francisco (2014). Violence and the Politics of Memory in a Global Context: An Overture. <em>Culture &amp; History Digital Journal, 3 (2)</em>. Retrieved from &lt;http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/chdj.2014.012&gt;</p><p>
Labanyi, Jo (2010). Testimonies of Repression. Methodological and Political Issues. In Jérez-Farrán, C. and Amago, S. (eds.), <em>Unearthing Franco&rsquo;s Legacy: Mass Graves and the Recovering of Historical Memory in Spain </em>(pp. 192-207)<em>.</em> Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.</p><p>
Loureiro, Ángel G. (2008). Argumentos patéticos. Historia y memoria de la guerra civil. <em>Claves de Razón Práctica</em>, 186, pp.18-25.</p><p>
Ricoeur, Paul (2009). <em>Memory, History, Forgetting</em>. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.</p><p>
Sánchez-biosca, Vicente (2006). <em>Cine y Guerra Civil Española. Del mito a la memoria</em>. Madrid: Alianza.</p><p>
Useros Martín, Ana (2014). Isaki Lacuesta. <em>Minerva. Revista del Círculo de Bellas Artes</em>, 22, pp. 82-87. Retrieved from &lt;http://www.revistaminerva.com/articulo.php?id=588&gt;</p><p>
White, Hayden (2005). The Public Relevance of Historical Studies: A Reply to Dirk Moses.<em> History and Theory</em>, 44, pp. 333-338.</p>